VA Fixed vs. Adjustable-Rate Mortgages: Which Loan is Best for You?

VA loans are offered in both fixed-rate and adjustable-rate mortgages (ARM) to eligible Veterans and active-duty military members. The choice between a fixed-rate and ARM can be a tricky one. The good news is that both options come with their own set of advantages and with favorable VA interest rates.

Let’s explore each mortgage type and highlight significant differences between the two to help choose the right one for you.

Differences Between VA Fixed and Adjustable-Rate Mortgages

After understanding what exactly fixed- and adjustable-rate mortgages are, let’s dive a little deeper into what separates the two.

Monthly Payment Predictability

Borrowers can more accurately budget their monthly expenses with a VA fixed-rate mortgage since the principal and interest portions of the payment remain unchanged over the loan’s life. This stability is especially valuable for individuals who prefer consistency in their financial planning.

VA ARMs offer lower initial rates, but after the fixed-rate period, the rate adjustment can lead to fluctuations in monthly payments. These changes can work in the borrower's favor if rates decrease, but they can also result in higher payments if rates rise.

Long-Term Financial Planning

Choosing a VA fixed-rate mortgage can be beneficial for buyers who plan to reside in the home for the foreseeable future. Borrowers can reliably anticipate the total interest paid over the loan term and make accurate projections for their future financial goals. They can also always look to refinance if mortgage rates fall enough to make it worthwhile.

VA adjustable-rate mortgages might be more suitable for borrowers who plan to sell or refinance their loan before the fixed-rate period ends. If you know you will be moving or refinancing within a few years, an ARM can offer lower initial rates, potentially resulting in significant interest savings. Every prospective buyer’s situation is different.

Economic Market Influence

VA fixed-rate mortgages protect borrowers from future interest rate increases, regardless of market conditions. This provides peace of mind and stability, especially during periods of rising interest rates.

On the other hand, VA ARMs are influenced by market conditions. If market interest rates decrease, borrowers may benefit from lower monthly payments. However if rates rise, monthly payments can increase and possibly result in financial instability.

Risk Tolerance and Future Plans

VA fixed-rate mortgages can be suitable for homeowners who prefer stability and have a lower risk tolerance. Ideally, this type of loan is perfect for those planning to stay in their homes for an extended period or seeking consistency in their mortgage payments.

VA adjustable-rate mortgages might be more appropriate for homeowners with a higher risk tolerance and shorter-term housing plans. If you anticipate a change in your financial situation or plan to move or refinance in the near future, an ARM may offer more initial savings.

VA Fixed-Rate Mortgages May Work Best If…

You Plan to Occupy the Home Long-Term

If you plan to live in the house for more than a few years, a fixed-rate mortgage may be best for you. ARMs often have lower initial rates than fixed-rate mortgages, which can increase significantly over time. Choosing a VA fixed-rate mortgage protects you from these rate increases.

Interest Rates are Rising

If you believe that interest rates are likely to rise in the future, a fixed-rate mortgage can lock in the current rate and protect you from future increases.

You Have a Fixed Income

If you're on a fixed income, such as a retirement pension, having a principal and interest payment that won't change can be especially beneficial. Unexpected increases in your mortgage payment could strain your budget.

You Can Afford Current Interest Rates

If you can afford the home you want with the current fixed rates, it might make more sense to choose a fixed-rate mortgage. You'll have the certainty of fixed principal and interest payments and won't have to worry about possible future rate increases.

VA Adjustable-Rate Mortgages May Work Best If…

You Plan to Occupy the Home Short-Term

If you’re planning to reside in the home for only a few years, a VA ARM may be the option for you. ARMs often have lower initial rates than fixed-rate mortgages, so if you sell the home before the rate adjusts upward, you could save money.

Interest Rates are Falling

If you believe that interest rates will fall in the future, then an ARM could be advantageous. However, predicting interest rates is notoriously difficult, so this is a high-risk strategy.

Your Annual Income is Expected to Increase

If you’re expecting a salary increase, an ARM could be the right option for you. This would allow you to budget for higher mortgage payments in the future when the rate adjusts.

VA Hybrid ARMs are Available

The VA offers hybrid ARMs that have a period of fixed interest rates (typically for the first 3-5 years) and then adjust annually. This combines some stability of a fixed-rate loan with the potential benefits of an adjustable-rate loan. VA ARMs also have what’s known as a 1/1/5 cap, which means the most the rate can increase in the first and all subsequent years is 1 percentage point, up to no more than 5 percentage points from where you started.